Home » Money » Economy of People

Economy of People

It’s a bizzy return-to-work week, and I don’t know how to say this any better.  This post, from 2013, is presented just as it was because so much of it is relevant.  This was elaborated on at length in my discussion series People’s Economics in 2015, but this is the summary.  I still believe that this is what we should be talking about rather than the nonsense which passes for “politics” today – and that nearly everyone is utterly missing the ability to analyze what is happening around all of us in any useful way.

The economic teachings of Pope Francis are a hot topic. People feel a need to weigh in on what he said whether they understand it or not. But it’s the simple fact that so many don’t understand where this comes from that is probably the most important point in the public debate.

To sum it up: Money should work for people, and not the other way around. That shouldn’t be controversial, but having forgotten this way of looking at things is may be at the heart of economic and social cycles. The simple answer is that it’s time we remembered. More to the point, that philosophy is at the heart of American tradition going back to our earliest days.

What it takes

What it takes

An Economy of People is not a radical teaching at all. Barataria has written on the topic in many different ways, especially outlining the difference between Capitalism, which we don’t really practice in its purest form, and Marketism. The latter is a belief in free markets and the power of people coming together freely to exchange for their own benefit. Capitalism, by contrast, is the belief that money will lead the way. The difference is not academic at all.

A free market is something of an ideal. Markets, by themselves, are almost never truly free. Anyone looking for an edge is going to take advantage of their unique position – or even build one to the best of their ability. There are many known “market failures” that cause markets to be less than free.

For example, let’s say you know something that no one else does. Perhaps you have developed a new way of building something or created a new invention that has not figured out yet. That’s an “Asymmetry of Information” that gives you an edge. It also means that your competition is at a disadvantage. Push this hard enough and you might even be able to develop a monopoly based on your ability to do or say something of value that no one else can.

Branding, as a marketing concept, is also about building a monopoly of sorts. If you can get into popular culture the idea that your purse, soft drink, or any other thing is the one true definition of coolness, then anyone who wants to be cool has to come to you to buy your product. You want “the real thing”? Buy it from the only place that has it.

Naturally, people learn from each other and knock off brands all the time. Given time and enough resources, markets will sort themselves out without a concerted effort to create a true monopoly through methods like buying out a resource in its entirety. But on the other end, not everyone necessarily has access to the same markets meaning that there is never true equality of opportunity.

That’s where the traditions of the United States come in, expressed through laws and programs throughout our history. Universal education became a standard in the 1820s in large part to give everyone the most basic access to markets. Slavery was outlawed for similar reasons, above and beyond the moral ones. The Sherman Anti-Trust Act of 1890 made explicit monopolies illegal. The New Deal re-organized many things, especially banking, to make sure that everyone had access to credit.

Hard money was hard to come by in the Panic of 1819

Hard money was hard to come by in the Panic of 1819

These examples from our history were chosen carefully. Each came at the end of a cycle of Depression. The first time that word was used was by President Monroe to describe the downturn of 1819. A serious downturn came in 1857 and had a lot to do with the Civil War. The Long Depression of the 1880s culminated with a renewed attention to the fair operation of business. The Great Depression of 1929 needed nearly everything to be sorted out before we could move forward.

It’s been noted here in the past that business cycles are getting longer, a fact neatly missed by Nikolai Kondratieff when he first proposed them. It seems as though as our life span increases everything is stretched out. That’s because they are more than business cycles – they are social and cultural turning points. The downturns occur when we conveniently forget what our Grandparents taught us, which were the lessons from the last Depression.

Here, in the fifth such Depression in US history, what we have forgotten is that money has to work for people. We let go of the ideal of a free market created not by natural forces but as a deliberate act of policy expressing our most basic values. Indeed, value and values are the same word – or at least they must be.

This Depression started because we forgot that money should be the slave of the Economy of People, not its master. The first step towards ending this cycle is simple to remember.

6 thoughts on “Economy of People

  1. The problem is we no longer have real money. We have Fiat money. Pieces of paper not backed by a Gold standard. The U.S. also has a 19 trillion dollar debt; which means that we as U.S citizens all own this debt; not of our own making. We don’t even have real money available to pay it back. The root cause is that we now have a government that no longer serves the people. It only serves itself. Aside from that, forget any tripe that comes out of the Vatican. It is the richest institution in the world. It promotes uncontrolled human breeding, overpopulation, champions diminishing resources, hides and protects Pedophiles and nickels and dimes its impoverished parishioners every week with a collection basket. You decry “Branding.” Then get rid of the most malicious brand on the planet: “The Pope.”
    More than half of everything the Vatican owns it stole. Yes, a free market. When you steal from people for 2000 years, it is indeed a “free market.’

    • “All money is a matter of belief.” – Adam Smith.
      “Money” as a concept is very different from “wealth”. It doesn’t really matter what we use to measure wealth, it matters how flows. And while the debt can be crippling, keep in mind that $2.8B of it, about 14%, is owned by the Federal Reserve. That is entirely fictional, in a sense.
      Government does not always serve the people, no, and that is a serious problem. But it’s hardly a new problem if you ask me.

    • Change your mind instead? 🙂 The economy is nothing more than a series of values made into a system. Changing the values changes the system more than anything else.

  2. Money is just a thing to help you get what you want. I see more and more people living very happily with less. Some of them are the happiest people I know. So it can’t be about money at least not in the end.

Like this Post? Hate it? Tell us!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s