Home » Nooze » Union


Memorial Day started as a commemoration of the hundreds of thousands killed in our Civil War.  It was a war that started because the nation could not tolerate being half free and half slave-owning any longer.  What won the day was one nation, once assembled, which could never pull apart.  Perpetual Union is now sanctified in blood and taken as a given.

While we pause to remember the sacrifices of those who came before us, Europe is deep into their own process for understanding what Union means to them.  It has been in the works for perhaps 200 years, or 2,000 if you want to start with Rome.  The bloodshed has been grave and terrible.

Does it really come down to stark choices like this for Europe?

Some time ago I was in the little town of Burghausen, Germany.  This is a place where people are more likely to call themselves “Bavarian” or “European” than German.  Tucked just under the Alps that hover over them to the south, this is the land where the Rhine and Danube rivers come breathtakingly close together.  The ancient highways brought people and goods from the North and the East equally.  It is, in many ways, the heart of Europe.

This little town has a curious tradition every year, known as “French Week”.  People from their sister city in Fumel, France come to visit and the town is festooned with red, white, and blue flags.  The menus in the restaurants are even replaced with ones in French.  They do it up in a big way, going as completely French as they can.  I asked Herr Miterer, the owner of the Hotel Post, how people really felt about European Union and the single currency – was this really going to work?

“It has to,” he replied.  “We’ve seen the alternative.”

Across the barriers of language and a lot of very bad history, people have little choice but to talk about Union and really do it up as a big show.  In the USofA, we’ve more or less assumed it for nearly 150 years – it’s simply a matter of faith at this point, no matter how much people gripe and complain.

But there is always some complaining.  More and more Union around the world means that definitions of people and nations are bound to become bigger and necessarily out of touch with the people that make up the nation.  Perhaps new technologies might make democracy much more workable in these big structures, but that process is also still muddling its way through.

Union will come to places where it simply has to, given how terrible the alternatives are.  We learned that lesson, and so did Europe.  Their job has been a bit harder.  The single currency floated without a true Federal Union of Europe was always more of a stepping-stone.  We may have tried to forget that was the plan all along, but Helmut Kohl, the man who presided over the reunification of Germany, knew exactly what was going on.  The lines were falling everywhere and people were free to trade, travel, and simply be together.

Today, markets around the world are being wracked by the turmoil in Europe.  Will the Euro fall apart? Nearly everyone, even here in the US, has heard the story by now and has some kind of opinion on what this thing called “Europe” really is.   What will happen to it, though?

The answer is that they are in that awkward stage in their relationship where they either move forward or fall apart.  That’s what the talk of Eurobonds is all about, a hesitant step without a lot of solid commitment.  This will soon shuffle into more and more talk about a real United States of Europe.

We learned our lesson long ago, even if we’re always working on the kinks as the advantages of Union play out against the advantages of local people working together, eye to eye.  Europe learned its lesson, too, even if it’s been terribly slow to push it together.

If we think this through, we know where the story has to go.  We especially know here in the USofA because of what we honor on this Memorial Day.

6 thoughts on “Union

  1. Interesting way to look at it. I also think they will go ahead and make a real union. What they tried to do with the Euro was a good idea but it just does not work without one government apparently.

    • It was a half-step and now they will have little choice but to take the whole leap together. I can’t see it going any other way, really. The Euro is too valuable to them, and to the world.

  2. “they are in that awkward stage in their relationship where they either move forward or fall apart.” Gold!

    • Thanks! I was going to write the whole piece on the theme of a relationship – it seems that they are about to open a joint checking account without being engaged. But … I demurred. 🙂

  3. In the United States entertainment has been a unifying force in our national cultural consciousness. Bing Crosby, Frank Sinatra, Louis Armstrong, Elvis Presley, Chuck Berry, James Brown. Their level of artistry was so high that it had a universal appeal. Their music had national appeal and worldwide appeal. They were ethnic in some senses of the term, but they were also worldwide capitalists, wanting to appeal to everyone, but always entertaining in English. The lucky thing is the US has language to bind us. You look at Bing, Frank, Louis, Elvis, Chuck, and James: they came from very humble backgrounds, but they seemed to have natural talent and they worked enormously hard. They wanted the best songs and the highest level of musicianship.

    • And that’s what the Eurovision Song Contest is all about! Sweden just won with … um, I guess I don’t follow it. But they had the same idea, turned into something more like “European Idol” long before we ever thought of it.
      You’re right about our popular culture, at its best. I’ve written before on the decline of Top 40, when everyone used to listen to the same stuff more or less. We don’t anymore. It is a problem, silly as it seems. Economics, politics, and culture are really all reflections of the same basic notions and impulses in the end, which is why I write about all of them at once.
      The lack of a meaningful politics in this nation comes from a lack of cultural and economic cohesion, I think. It’s very natural. But we can do our best to pull it back together.

Like this Post? Hate it? Tell us!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s