If you’re a fan of NFL football, you know that the fourth quarter is when all the action comes in most games. The teams that win consistently are the teams that get tougher in the last 15 minutes week after week. The economy is no different, relying on the holiday season to make or break any given year.
Last year, Hurricane Sandy made for a wet and limp holiday season. There are many good reasons to believe that 2013 will be much better – except, of course for the government shutdown. We don’t know where that will leave us until long after it’s over. But as we check in with Barataria’s predictions for the year we can get some idea where we stand heading into the critical last quarter.
Except, of course, for the final unemployment stats. But let’s check out what we can and see how we stand for now.
Predictions: Accelerating job growth, reduced gap between youth & overall unemployment.
Results: Job growth up 11% over 2012 YTD, Youth unemployment falling faster.
The ADP job report for September showed a disappointing gain of only 166k jobs that month, or 486k for 3Q13. That’s up a decent 11% overall year to date. It’s not bad, but it’s not the 200k gains each month we were hoping for. At least the trend is positive and the rate of job gains each month is accelerating.
We don’t have the official Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) report for September due to the shutdown, but as of August the official headline unemployment rate (U3) had fallen to 7.3% and among 20-24 year olds had fallen to 13.0%. That’s a gap of only 5.7% between the two, showing that youth unemployment is finally falling faster than the overall. It’s a sign that employers are hiring people with less experience and taking a chance by investing in young people. That’s the one prediction that didn’t look as good, but it’s finally coming in.
Prediction: Normalizing in the 60-70 range.
Result: Even better!
The conference board indicator consumer confidence slipped below 80 to 79.7. That probably reflects the impending shutdown that dominated the news at the end of the quarter, and may slip even more if the shutdown continues. As it stands, consumers are in a better buying mood than they have been for many years entering the big holiday season, so we could still have a good shopping season. It all depends on how the game plays out in Washington – barring any other disturbances other than the ones our supposed “leaders” are inflicting on the economy.
Prediction: Remaining high.
Result: Still good!
Corporate profits are up and staying up through 2013, which is the main reason the S&P500 is up 15% year to date. The normally calm summer had a better than usual gain in the stock market, meaning there is plenty of cash to start hiring. That’s the main reason to watch corporate profits as we wait for a turnaround.
The net gain in jobs over the quarter showed that 38% were from large corporations, which is all we really care about. But this is not yet a wave of hiring by big corporations. That has to come in the fourth quarter, which is what this prediction really called. For now, we have to be happy that corporate profits are remaining high and see if it starts to turn into general growth.
Prediction: Continue rising.
Result: The rapid rise of earlier in the year has calmed, but it still up.
The Case-Shiller index of real estate values in 20 cities across the US is up 12% year over year, a very healthy gain. That data is a bit slow to come in, with July 2013 being the last month we have a reading for. It’s very positive news, but there are signs that it is slowing some at the end of the summer. We don’t want another bubble, so anything over 10% is actually a bit scary at the high end. It’s been a good year for real estate.
What do we have overall? Everything is going exactly as Barataria predicted – but we have yet to see how the shutdown will change the numbers for the fourth quarter. If this is a tough economy it’ll blow right through the nonsense in Washingtoon, but we can’t say for sure just how good it really is. Hey, it wouldn’t be a game if there wasn’t a good challenge at the end of it, right?
Except, of course, this isn’t a game. This have been going very well in 2013 and overall we have turned the corner into reliable economic progress. Let’s hope it hasn’t been screwed up.
I know it’s not nearly enough but the economy is kind of strong despite not getting much support from the government. If the job growth is accelerating that does point to a recovery soon. How many jobs did we gain in 2013 total and how far behind are we what we lost in the downturn?
From Jan 2008 (peak) to Jan 2010 (trough) we lost 8.8M jobs. We have made up 7.1M of them since then. In 2013 so far we have gained 1.47M, so we are running about 2M gain per year and should be back at the level we were before by June 2014.
However, it does pick up in 4Q. Last year at this time we only had 1.32M gained, but picked up a full 632k in 4Q12. So there is always reason to hope – barring, of course, an extended shutdown or even worse a default.
The Feds can only screw up a good thing at this point. We are getting out of the woods, if slowly. Keep in mind that the workforce is still expanding (and should until 2017 when more Boomers retire) so we do need 5-6M more jobs from where we are now, meaning full employment is not likely until that retirement wave hits at this rate.
Excellent analysis as always. Gaining 2 million jobs a year is something but it still doesn’t look like enough. With the shutdown I guess we won’t have regular updates on a lot of information so we can’t see how it is going until it is over?
Bingo. It’s a point worth thinking about. Not having info is reason for the markets to start panicking by itself.
Pingback: Ready to Panic? | Barataria - The work of Erik Hare
Pingback: Dissin’ the Jobs Report | Barataria - The work of Erik Hare
Pingback: Corporate Profits – A Bad Thing? | Barataria - The work of Erik Hare