Eric Cantor’s primary loss may have been the shock that finally changes everything. That’s an awful lot to ask, but the early signs are that the various forms of establishment in politics and media were caught completely off guard. The response so far has been careful and even intelligent as the constantly wagging tongues have stopped long enough to give more thoughtful voices an opening.
Whether or not there is a permanent change remains to be seen. But the easy explanations quickly sank from their own weight while something that usually lurks much deeper is floating to the surface. If we can change the conversation, we can change the politics. Crossies?
It’s possible to make too much of the loss. Cantor was facing a partisan primary in which only 12% of the eligible voters bothered to show up, so it may not be representative of anything. But the loss of a Majority Leader, the first ever, is so serious that the conversation in the press simply has to focus on what happened. The first pass at that came right after the loss – it was over immigration reform, a key point his opponent hammered at.
That simply doesn’t make sense in a suburban Virginia district, so something remarkable happened. The press quickly dropped that line and started focusing on the elephant that was in the room along with a lot of people who work in Washington who live in that district. Cantor, and Congress, are hugely unpopular.
But it is more than just being unpopular, and more than just not being able to get anything done. The key to this moment is that Cantor and his party have made Congress largely irrelevant. That message took over the press quickly and has, so far, stayed with us.
Consider this piece in the very conservative National Journal looking for a unity between the far right and the far left. The common enemy? The “elites” who own Congress and have made it ineffective for anything but their needs.
This takes me back to a piece I wrote in 1999 on how politics has become increasingly irrelevant. The gist of it is that the old labels of “liberal” and “conservative” are used despite the fact that their traditional use has no meaning in today’s world. I invite everyone to read it, understanding that it’s a bit dated by now.
The reason that our axis of political thought is broken is simply that politics in a nation of 330 million people cannot be describe in one dimension. When handles like “left” and “right” become useful it’s only for a single issue, a single moment, a single movement. There is a tremendous amount of change happening right now, and the old terms that are fixed in political lexicon are simply meaningless.
It’s not Cantor or the Republicans that voters find irrelevant. It’s everything.
In a way, the real issue here is that in a social sense a lie is not the opposite of the truth. A lie points the way to the truth by shining language into a dark corner. Language is more than an abstract concept like “truth”, it has a human face. The more someone denies something, the more you know it has to be true.
In this sense, the opposite of truth is more like (cow puckey), or a complete disregard for whether something is true or not. Distraction is also the opposite of truth, such as talking about celebrities when the world is full of suffering. There are many things that never point their way to the truth of our world as well as an outright lie can.
We’ve been wallowing in something opposite truth for a long time because we lack the language to describe what is going on. Left contrasts with right as black contrasts with white – but how would that language describe up? Or red?
What happened on Tuesday was more than Eric Cantor losing for one very good but pathetic reason. When the chattering classes and the power brokers were left speechless the stillness of the moment allowed a few quieter voices to be heard. They have been murmuring for a long time that the shrill noise is meaningless and irrelevant.
Something did change, although it changed slowly over a long time. Forces that relied on the old establishment for job security couldn’t contemplate the gradual change, or when they did they didn’t want anyone to notice. It’s finally as big as the elephant in a very Republican district and can’t be ignored.
If all it took to get us here was to sacrifice Eric Cantor, we should have done it a long time ago. But this is about much more than this. The powers of the establishment have been humbled. The time has come to seize the discussion and make our language work again. That’s the only way we can have a productive discussion about what this nation really needs.
Love Song: I and Thou
BY ALAN DUGAN
Nothing is plumb, level, or square:
the studs are bowed, the joists
are shaky by nature, no piece fits
any other piece without a gap
or pinch, and bent nails
dance all over the surfacing
like maggots. By Christ
I am no carpenter. I built
the roof for myself, the walls
for myself, the floors
for myself, and got
hung up in it myself. I
danced with a purple thumb
at this house-warming, drunk
with my prime whiskey: rage.
Oh I spat rage’s nails
into the frame-up of my work:
it held. It settled plumb,
level, solid, square and true
for that great moment. Then
it screamed and went on through,
skewing as wrong the other way.
God damned it. This is hell,
but I planned it. I sawed it,
I nailed it, and I
will live in it until it kills me.
I can nail my left palm
to the left-hand crosspiece but
I can’t do everything myself.
I need a hand to nail the right,
a help, a love, a you, a wife.
John Kennedy said this about poetry and Robert Frost:
“Our national strength matters, but the spirit which informs and controls our strength matters just as much. This was the special significance of Robert Frost. He brought an unsparing instinct for reality to bear on the platitudes and pieties of society. His sense of the human tragedy fortified him against self-deception and easy consolation. “I have been” he wrote, “one acquainted with the night.” And because he knew the midnight as well as the high noon, because he understood the ordeal as well as the triumph of the human spirit, he gave his age strength with which to overcome despair. At bottom, he held a deep faith in the spirit of man, and it is hardly an accident that Robert Frost coupled poetry and power, for he saw poetry as the means of saving power from itself. When power leads men towards arrogance, poetry reminds him of his limitations. When power narrows the areas of man’s concern, poetry reminds him of the richness and diversity of his existence. When power corrupts, poetry cleanses. For art establishes the basic human truth which must serve as the touchstone of our judgment.”
Eric Cantor lost because he is a horrible person. I wouldn’t read too much into this. If the voters in his district figured out his slick doubletalk then they get my thanks no matter what kind of loon they put in his place.
Eric Cantor probably lost because the voters finally realized hes a horrible human being.