Did you hit the stores for “doorbuster” deals and a mad rush for great deals? If you did, you’re one of a smaller group every year as Black Friday and its even darker sibling on Thursday become a feature of Thanksgiving past.
The final data is not in, especially with “Cyber Monday” still in front of us. But this weekend was particularly weak and, if the past is any indication, a sign of a bleak holiday shopping season. But no one thinks this will hold as shopping patterns are changing. The forecast remains for a robust gain of 4.1% year over year.
The death of the Black Friday frenzy is a big story of the year if this pulls out.
The National Retail Federation (NRF) has already performed its survey of the weekend. They found that total traffic out at physical brick-and-mortar stores was down about 5.2% over 2013, with about 66M people or 55% of all those who plan to spend money this season out. That comes from a survey of 4600 shoppers who were willing to stop for a moment to answer the surveys.
ShopperTrak, which surveys retail outlets, reported a big increase in Thanksgiving Day sales (up 55%) and a small drop on Black Friday (-7%) over 2013. They see the entire weekend running about $12.3B, about the same as last year at retail stores.
Fewer shoppers running up the same tab is actually a good sign. People may be spending more time with their families and shopping online rather than going out. They may also be waiting for more discounts later in the season, as happened last year.
For this reason, the estimates are going to hold for now. A flat Black Friday shopping season doesn’t mean a thing to the long haul. The word from the NRF is that Black Friday and the rush for deals is a thing of the past:
“A strengthening economy that changes consumers’ reliance on deep discounts, a highly competitive environment, early promotions and the ability to shop 24/7 online all contributed to the shift witnessed this weekend,” said NRF President and CEO Matthew Shay. “We are excited to be witnessing an evolutionary change in holiday shopping by both consumers and retailers, and expect this trend to continue in the years ahead.”
Why should we expect that this flat weekend shapes up as expected as a decent gain in overall spending? “We need to be cautious about looking at a single day or two in projecting the season’s total,” according to Bill Martin, founder of ShopperTrak. “In 2013, the Black Friday weekend produced a 1% gain, underperforming the 3.1% gain for the entire season. There is a significant amount energy left in the consumer with 7 of the top 10 sales days of the year yet to come, including Super Saturday which is projected to be the number one spending day of the year.”
“Super Saturday” is the Saturday before Christmas, this year on the 20th. If it does pass “Black Friday” for the first time ever, it will prove that the mad rush that threatens to devour Thanksgiving like so much turkey and gravy may finally be beaten back.
No matter what, shopping is evolving. The expectation is for much higher growth in online retail overall, meaning there must be a decline in brick-and-mortar retail. This alone will tend to spread out the shopping season, as people can go online whenever it is convenient for them.
The success of this season can’t be told in just one weekend, at least according to the professionals that track it. They’re telling us to not worry and let the reports of a weak season go as a ghost of Christmases past. That’s all just as well.
We will see by the 20th if this season is what has been predicted – and probably not a day before.
I didn’t go to it. I waited until Saturday, when it was still busy but not a rush
That makes sense to me. I don’t fault going out shopping, really, and I know many families do it together. Anything like that I have to support. But the whole thing got very silly and destructive. “Black Friday” as a concept, toned down a bit, could be OK.
Busy, but not a rush sounds great! Hope you had a good time.
I hope it is dead. It is a national disgrace. How many people were killed or injured this year? The news didn’t have anyone which I don’t believe.
Also, didn’t you say that the reason for black friday was that they didn’t have real-time data back whenever it started? So the whole point is mute.
I do not think there were any serious injuries or deaths this year. So the worst is over.
Glad you remembered that from this piece from last year. 🙂 https://erikhare.com/2013/11/25/black-friday-psychology/
Super Saturday just makes more sense. Let us know when the reports come in (I am sure you will).
I sure will. 🙂 But we have to wait 3 weeks.
I actually went to a Target on Thanksgiving evening, but not for the deals. I was glad they were open for NyQuil and cough drops. There were about as many people there you’d expect to see on a weeknight.
That’s why I’d hate to have this done through a law – there’s always a need for a few things to be open for small emergencies. If we can just stop the frenzy it’d all be OK, IMHO.
I can’t believe this is still a thing. Who is willing to risk death for a cheap TV?
As a postscript, we have the Comcast data for online sales.
“Cyber Monday” sales were up 17% from 2013 to $2B, and overall the 5-day period from Thanksgiving to Monday saw a 24% rise to $6.5B.
The $12.3B figure above appears to include online sales, so it appears that online shopping may have exceeded brick and mortar for the first time. Given that these are all estimates I want to hold off on that for the final figures, but it appears that what has really killed Black Friday is online shopping.
Pingback: Winter Arrives? | Barataria - The work of Erik Hare
Pingback: A Bit Darker | Barataria - The work of Erik Hare
Pingback: 2016 Holiday Shopping Forecast | Barataria - The work of Erik Hare