Home » Nooze » A Spirit, not an Event

A Spirit, not an Event

The tenth anniversary of 9/11 was nearly impossible to avoid.  Coverage of remembrances dominated the news, special features dotted the cable teevee lineup, and star spangled displays opened a season of NFL football.  The most pressing moments for me, however, were the questions of my kids who were too young on that day to remember it.  The stories that washed over the nation have come to them as small sprays from a quieted tide that still runs a bit angry at times.

Like many news events, clarity came through their eyes.  It has to, after all, since much of this will define their generation.  There is a unity that will also never be forgotten.

The response to a Barataria retrospective on the economy over the last ten years shocked and somewhat saddened me.  “We let bin Laden win” echoed the tale of ten years of wandering that has marked our nation since.  That wasn’t my intention when I wrote the piece.  Without any mention of the war in Iraq, our massive military spending, or calls for civility  you readers connected the dots.  Something went horribly wrong on that day as the towers fell.  Our hearts fell with them.

The coverage of the anniversary brought back a different feeling of resolution and strength.  Right afterwards our horror and sadness reflected back on us as unity, a call to stand together.  Remembering 9/11 brought forward one absolutely critical memory that we should never have let go – the nation took its biggest defeat in a long time as a challenge to move forward, together, and achieve greatness again.

And it has not happened.

We can crow about finally getting bin Laden after so long or deliberately see the ongoing war in Afghanistan as some kind of victory if we want, but the main feeling that has washed over the nation in the last ten years has been division and defeat.  The attack made us stand up and sing together, but when the crises came home we were more likely to shout and demand that we get our way.  And so we have fallen much like the World Trade Center, our own weight collapsing in place, floor by floor, with an astonishing speed and a terrible cloud of dust.

There are many reasons to hope that we are at a turning point in the national discussion.  The debt ceiling crisis engaged the public and laid bare how broken politics has become.  Unemployment and foreclosure have become so common that shame has been wrung out of discussing them publicly.  Yet what might give us the most hope that we are finally serious enough to tackle the fundamental problems of this nation was the revival of that 9/11 spirit – that we cannot be humbled because we stand united.  As President Obama said in an editorial for the day:

On a day when others tried to divide us, we can regain the sense of common purpose that stirred in our hearts 10 years ago. As a nation, we face difficult challenges, and as citizens in a democratic society we engage in vigorous debates about the future. But as we do, let’s never forget the lesson we learned anew 10 years ago — that our differences pale beside what unites us and that when we choose to move forward together, as one American family, the United States doesn’t just endure, we can emerge from our tests and trials stronger than before.

My kids do not remember the attacks or what life was like without constant orange alert.  Recounting  9/11 unity came as a surprise because, as is typical with kids, they witnessed what we have done and set aside what we said we would do.  Yet Dad had a few stories to tell them in memoriam that stretched beyond heroism and horror.  There was a greater story of a nation mobilized, ready to take on its challenges together.  Like any hero’s journey it twists, turns and wanders to where the lesson is explained by its dark opposite.  But that story has not ended yet.

The unity of that story is the unity of our people.  There is a generation that will be defined by the story and how it is finally written.  How have we defined the world they will inherit, both in fact and fable?

12 thoughts on “A Spirit, not an Event

  1. Thanks, Anna! It struck me how much I had forgotten this spirit as well, so I should make it clear that I’m as guilty of what I describe here as anyone else.

  2. If the problem is not getting along I think there is only one side we can issue blame. Democrats went along with all the wars and all the deficit spending when the Republicans used 9/11 unity against us to stop any debate at all. So if you want to know why people are so jaded its because unity has been a one-way street.

  3. Jim: I’m doing my best to reach out and not put this in partisan terms. If we can all cut out the games right now I’ll just forget who is to blame for everything and we can get right at fixing things. I’m sure we’ll have some serious disagreements as to how to do that so it’s best that we all concentrate on what we have to do rather than who is to blame for what.

    That’s the message I hope we can take from this, at least.

  4. I’d bet some people would read this as a challenge and take it pretty bad. That would tell you a lot about them and what they really care about.

  5. Jack, Sheryl: If someone wants to take this as a challenge I do think we’ll know who they are. I think it’s long past time to put up with partisan games and silliness.

  6. Reclaiming a spirit of national unity is a nice concept, but count me as skeptical about the country moving in that direction, at least in the short term. I expect the 2012 election to get very divisive and ugly as it heats up.

    I don’t have a problem with outreach to conservative voters, who have just been misled in the opinions they’ve formed on confusing issues. I think trying to work with modern GOP leaders is a complete waste of time. I no longer try to determine if these so called leaders are stupid or evil, as I think they are varying degrees of both. (most more stupid than evil, which is a strong word, but I couldn’t think of a lighter weight synonym.) How’s that for a spirit of unity : )

  7. Laurie: I agree with you on Republican leadership, but I’m also pretty skeptical of Democratic leadership. I think we’ve hit the point where it’s up to people to put pressure on the leaders to do the right thing. I’m trying to reach out to ordinary Republicans who are, from my read, pretty disappointed as well.

    Think about the debt ceiling issue – if you’re someone who is Republican because you manage your stock portfolio and support business generally, how can you be happy with the volatility that has hit the markets since that? How can you even imagine risking default?

    There are a lot of people I don’t agree with generally who seem to have a common interest with me right now, and I’m trying to reach out to them. Screw the leadership. We need people to speak out on both sides for sanity.

    I’m taking some advice Jack gave me a full month ago on this one. I’m also going to say that I’m for Obama no matter what and we Progressives have to support him where we can and give him space. I was disappointed in the AJA but I know why he started where he did – and I support him. Let’s work to give him room for the next step as we back him on this one.

    The 2012 election might get ugly, sure. But the voices of reason won’t have a chance unless they organize – and start doing it now. Will it work? I hope so. But it sure won’t work if we don’t get going and try.

  8. I do not see people getting past the lines that divide us easily. But it is worth trying. I know a lot of people are upset now. Many are talking about things for the first time so that is good. I agree that there has been a turning point this summer and I hope it lasts.

  9. Pingback: Faith in … Us? | Barataria – The work of Erik Hare

Like this Post? Hate it? Tell us!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s